Depression in Older Adults
Tracey Holsinger, M.D.
Fellow in Geriatric Psychiatry
Northwestern University Medical School
Depression is an important cause of suffering among older adults as well as a significant contributor to the morbidity and mortality caused by other illnesses. Depressive symptoms have been associated with increased risks of myocardial infarction and death(1) and mood changes have been found to herald cardiovascular events.(2) Rates of depression are higher among patients with diabetes(3) and arthritis.(4) Twenty-five to thirty percent of stroke patients are depressed at the time of initial interview. Of note, depression is more common with left sided infarcts and more common with more anterior infarcts. (5) The diagnosis of major depression is often overlooked and with it the chance to intervene in a treatable condition, frequently with good outcomes.
Estimates of the prevalence
of depression vary according to the criteria used for diagnosis
and the living situation of the survey population. Data from the
Epidemiological Catchment Area (ECA) study of more than 18,000
adults conducted in five sites(6) found lifetime
rates of depression of 2% of men and 3% of women over the age
65 while 15% of geriatric respondents had some current depressive
symptoms. In a primary care geriatric clinic population, the prevalence
has been estimated at 5%. In nursing homes, estimates have ranged
from 15-25% at any given point with an incidence of 13% per year.(7, 8)
Appropriate diagnosis and treatment of depression can not only
ease the suffering associated with the depression itself and eliminate
the excess disability added by the condition but also lower the
mortality of direct and indirect self destructive behavior. The
highest suicide rates occur in men over 75 years old. (9)
The general population suicide rate is 12.4 per 100,000 while
among 80-84 year olds it is 26.5 per 100,000.7 Indirect self destructive
behavior, such as not eating and medication noncompliance, is
much more common than suicide, and has been associated with decreased
survival. (10)
There is a tendency to view suicide as a reasonable alternative
in elderly populations, but only 5-10% of the older adults who
make attempts have a terminal illness while 95% have a psychiatric
illness, usually major depression. Elderly white males without
a spouse have the highest suicide risk.(11)
More than 75% of the elderly who commit suicide saw their primary
care provider in the month preceding their death. Generally
they are having a first major depressive episode with moderately
severe symptoms.7 The elderly are less likely than younger patients
to make a suicidal gesture as an attempt to get help. Only 7%
of unsuccessful suicide attempts are made by the elderly, and
75% of these had lethal intent.(9) Those who
do survive an attempt remain a high risk group for future attempts.
There are many barriers to the diagnosis of this treatable illness.
Many older adults consider depressive symptoms to be a "normal"
part of aging and may not report their symptoms to a physician.
Many physicians also attribute some depressive symptoms to old
age or other physical infirmities. Some elderly patients with
depression present with "failure to thrive" rather than
specific complaints.(12) Often a mood disturbance
is not reported by an elderly patient, or the mood disturbance
may be less prominent than multiple somatic complaints. However,
it is possible to diagnose depression in the setting of medical
causes of depressive symptoms. (13)
Diagnosis of a major depressive episode as defined by the American
Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, (DSM IV) (7) Dysthymic
disorder is diagnosed when a chronically depressed mood (more
days than not for at least two years) is present with two of the
above mentioned symptoms. A helpful mnemonic for remembering the
depressive symptoms is SAD FACES:
Sleep Appetite/Anhedonia Dysphoria |
Fatigue Agitation/Anhedonia Concentration (decreased) Esteem (decreased) Suicidal |
While laboratory tests
can and should be used to rule out medical causes of depression,
there are no laboratory tests that are useful in making the diagnosis
of depression. As in younger patients the dexamethasone suppression
test is often abnormal, but it is not specific enough to be relied
upon for diagnosing depression.(11) Recommended
laboratory studies to rule out other causes of mood disturbance
include thyroid functions, levels of B12 and folate, and basic
blood chemistries. Imaging studies are indicated only if there
are history or physical exam findings suggesting a neurologic
disorder that would alter the treatment plan.
There are a variety of safe and effective treatment options for
depressed elders. Of the many antidepressants available, none
have demonstrated efficacy superior to the others; however, the
serotonin re-uptake inhibitors have been associated with fewer
side effects and therefore may inspire more compliance. The various
classes of antidepressants are characterized below with the most
common side effects and the most worrisome side effects. When
beginning a patient on an antidepressant it is important to stress
that response may take up to 12-13 weeks to develop, much longer
than the six weeks required for younger adults. (15)
Approximately 60% of depressed older adults respond to antidepressants
(15,16) leaving many patients
with residual symptoms. Both individual and group psychotherapy
can be helpful in addressing these issues and residual symptoms.
The decision of when it is appropriate to discontinue effective
antidepressant therapy is under current study. In patients who
have an illness characterized by recurrent major depressive episodes,
the continuation of therapy at the doses used to treat an acute
episode significantly reduces the chances of recurrence.
|
|
|
|
sexual dysfxn |
serotonin syndrome induced mania |
|
dry mouth, weight gain |
|
|
|
|
|
dry mouth, nervousness, nausea |
induced mania |
|
|
|
|
dry mouth |
|
|
|
|
Trazodone is an antidepressant
that few patients can tolerate in the doses necessary for antidepressant
efficacy. Because tolerance does not develop and because trazodone
has no anti-cholinergic side effects, it is a reasonable sleep
aid. Patients should be warned about the commonly occurring orthostatic
hypotension and the much less common priapism.
Electroconvulsive therapy remains a safe and effective therapy
for depression in the elderly. Indications for ECT include a treatment
refractory depression, a life threatening situation where rapid
response is required (usually a patient who has stopped eating
and drinking or is acutely suicidal), and patient preference.
ECT is also the most effective treatment for psychotic depression.
(17)
Most cases of geriatric depression are successfully treated by
the primary care physician. Psychiatric referral is appropriate
for psychotherapy, for the acutely ill patient who has suicidal
ideation, or for the patient who has a depression with psychotic
symptoms. A referral for psychiatric evaluation and treatment
may be helpful in cases where the diagnosis is unclear or when
antidepressant trials fail.
1 Barefoot JC, Schroll M. Symptoms of
depression, acute myocardial infarction, and total mortality in
a community sample. Circulation 1996; 93(11)1976-80.
[Citation]
2 Wassertheil-Smoller S, Applegate WB,
Buge K, Chang CJ, Davis BR, Grimm R, Kostis J, Pressel S, Schron
E. Change in depression as a precursor of cardiovascular events,
SHEP cooperative research group. Archives of Internal Medicine
1996; 156(5):553-561.
[Citation]
3 Gavard JA, Lustman PJ, Clouse RE. Prevalence
of depression in adults with diabetes. Diabetes Care 1993;
16(8):1167-78.
[Citation]
4 Smedstad LM, Vaglum P, Kvien TK, Moum
T. The relationship between self reported pain and sociodemographic
variables, anxiety, and depressive symptoms in rheumatoid arthritis.
Journal of Rheumatology 1995; 22(3):514-20.
[Citation]
5 Reichman WE, Neuropsychiatric aspects
of cerebrovascular diseases and tumors. in Comprehensive Textbook
of Psychiatry, 6th ed. Williams and Wilkins, New York; 1995.
6 Fombonne E. Increased rates of depression:
update of epidemiological findings and analytic problems. Acta
Psychiatrica Scandinavica 1994; 90:145-56.
[Citation]
7 Concensus Panel, Diagnosis and treatment
of depression in late life. Journal of the American Medical
Association 1992; 268(8):1018-24.
[Citation]
8 Slater SL, Katz IR. Prevalence of depression
in the aged: formal calculations versus clinical facts. Journal
of the American Geriatrics Society 1995; 43:78-79.
[Citation]
9 Draper BM. Prevention of suicide in
old age. The Medical Journal of Australia 1995; 162:533-34.
[Citation]
10 Nelson FL, Farberow NL. Indirect self-destructive
behavior in hte elderly nursing home patient. Journal of Gerontology
1980; 35(6):949-57.
[Citation]
11 Consensus statement, NIH reseases statement
on depression in the elderly. American Family Physician
1992, 45(2):801-02,808.
[Citation]
12 Sarkisian CA, Lachs MS. "Failure
to thrive" in older adults. Annals of Internal Medicine
1996;124:1072-78.
[Citation]
13 Koenig HG, Pappas P, Holsinger T, Bachar
JR, Assessing diagnostic approaches to depression in medically
ill older adults. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
1995; 43(5):472-78.
[Citation]
14 American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic
and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. Washington
DC, American Psychiatric Association, 1994.
15 Reynolds CF, Treatment of depression
in late life. American Journal of Medicine 1994; 97(6A):39S-46S.
[Citation]
16 Martin LM, Fleming KC, Evans JM, Recognition
and management of anxiety and depression in elderly patients.
Mayo Clinic Proceedings 1995; 70:999-1006.
[Citation]
17 American Psychiatric Association: The
Practice of Electroconvulsive Therapy: Recommendations for Treating,
Training, and Privileging. Washington DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 1990.